Google permits advertiser fingerprinting as UK ICO warns of legal risks
This article examines the legal and technical landscape of cookieless tracking, such as browser fingerprinting and IP matching, in light of evolving EU and North American regulations. It emphasizes that these techniques often fall under strict consent requirements for analytics and advertising, despite being marketed as cookieless solutions.
Key Takeaways
- Google's February 2025 policy update allows advertisers to use device fingerprinting, reversing a 2019 stance that called the practice a subversion of user choice.
- The UK Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) labeled the move 'irresponsible,' noting that businesses do not have free rein to track without valid consent.
- EU regulators confirmed in Guidelines 2/2023 that Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive applies to reading any data from a device, effectively mandating opt-in consent for fingerprinting.
- Recent enforcement includes a September 2025 fine of €325 million against Google by France's CNIL for tracking violations and invalid consent mechanisms.
Why It Matters
The reintroduction of fingerprinting into major ad stacks creates a high-stakes compliance gap for streaming platforms and digital publishers. While technical tools now promise '100% accuracy' by bypassing cookie rejection, the legal reality in the EU and UK remains tethered to explicit user consent. As browsers like Safari and Firefox continue to harden technical defenses, the industry faces a fracturing market where measurement strategies must choose between deterministic accuracy and regulatory safety. Streaming professionals should prepare for increased scrutiny of 'cookieless' vendors, as regulators signal they will target the reading of hardware signals with the same rigor previously reserved for traditional cookies.
Additional Context
The regulatory landscape surrounding digital tracking has intensified throughout 2025 and 2026 as authorities target both technical methods and market dominance. Per a September 2025 report from Goodwin Law, the French data protection authority (CNIL) fined Google €325 million for collecting invalid consent and displaying unauthorized ads, explicitly citing the company’s history of cookie-related violations as an aggravating factor. This move coincided with a broader European Commission push against Google's integrated ad tech stack, which resulted in a separate €2.95 billion antitrust penalty in late 2025 for distorting competition in the display advertising sector, according to Scidaproject and Thomson Reuters reporting from January 2026.
Simultaneously, the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) has formalized its 'maximalist' interpretation of tracking rules. Per Snellman and InfoTrust in early 2026, the EDPB's Guidelines 2/2023 clarified that any technology that gains access to information stored on 'terminal equipment'—including pixels, IP matching, and unique identifiers—requires opt-in consent regardless of whether the data is considered personal. This regulatory hardening occurs as the European Commission officially withdrew the proposed ePrivacy Regulation in February 2025 due to a lack of legislative consensus, leaving the existing ePrivacy Directive and national laws as the primary enforcement frameworks for the foreseeable future, as noted by Cookiebot in July 2026.
In the U.S., the shift toward state-level privacy enforcement has mirrored some European concerns through the lens of consumer protection. According to MediaPost in August 2026, federal courts have moved to restrict Google's exclusive distribution contracts for search and browsing, a development that complicates how programmatic supply chain technologies are deployed across the open web. These parallel pressures from antitrust and privacy regulators are forcing a re-evaluation of the entire programmatic advertising supply chain, as platforms can no longer rely on cookieless identity infrastructure to bypass evolving privacy standards, a shift further complicated by .
Read full article at enalitica.com
Enjoy our coverage?
Add StreamingMeme as a preferred source on Google to see more of our streaming news at the top of your Search results.
Add as preferred source