AWS benchmarks NDI vs JPEG XS, finds 4K bitrate efficiency gains
AWS researchers conducted an independent benchmark of NDI SpeedHQ and JPEG XS codecs for live cloud production workflows, testing image fidelity and generational quality loss using PSNR metrics. The study evaluated both codecs on AWS EC2 instances, concluding that while JPEG XS provides higher absolute quality, NDI SpeedHQ performs more efficiently at lower bitrates.
Key Takeaways
- NDI SpeedHQ delivers higher PSNR than JPEG XS at lower bitrates, specifically using only 2x bitrate for 4K over 1080p versus JPEG XS's 4x requirement.
- JPEG XS supports higher maximum quality and bitrate ceilings that NDI SpeedHQ cannot reach due to integrated codec limits.
- Both codecs maintained high signal integrity across eight encode-decode generations, with less than 0.5 dB of PSNR loss.
- Benchmarking was performed on Amazon EC2 C6id.12xlarge instances using Netflix’s Sparks open content at 60 fps.
Why It Matters
The validation of mezzanine codecs in the cloud accelerates the transition from uncompressed SDI workflows to bandwidth-efficient IP environments. For broadcasters, NDI’s efficiency at lower bitrates makes it ideal for dense cloud-based vision mixing and graphics insertion where instance network costs are a factor. Conversely, JPEG XS’s high-fidelity performance remains the standard for tier-1 sports contribution requiring minimal latency. This study removes guesswork for engineers architecting long signal chains, confirming both protocols are stable for multi-generational processing. Watch for more software-defined production vendors to integrate NDI 6, which recently expanded support for 10-bit and 14-bit color depth to close the quality gap with JPEG XS.
Additional Context
The AWS benchmarking study confirms a broader industry trend toward codec-agnostic cloud production environments. Per an AWS announcement in March 2025, the cloud provider added native NDI output support to AWS Elemental MediaConnect, allowing users to convert HEVC or AVC transport streams directly into NDI SpeedHQ for VPC-based workflows. This follow's earlier integrations of JPEG XS for AWS Cloud Digital Interface (CDI), which targets sub-frame latency requirements for uncompressed-equivalent workflows.
Recent product updates from vendors like Evertz and intoPIX at IBC 2024 highlight the competitive landscape for these mezzanine standards. Per Evertz (August 2024), the company’s Reflektor platform now supports both NDI version 6.0 and JPEG XS for cloud transcoding, reflecting an industry-wide need to bridge ground-to-cloud signal paths. Furthermore, intoPIX introduced a new "TDC" profile for JPEG XS in late 2024, claiming a 2x increase in compression efficiency to challenge NDI’s traditional dominance in bandwidth-constrained 1GbE networks.
NDI’s evolution also accelerated with the April 2024 release of NDI 6, which introduced standardized 10-bit color support to better compete with the high-fidelity broadcast standards typical of JPEG XS deployments. According to NDI’s technical leadership, these updates specifically target the tier-1 broadcast market, aiming to reduce color banding in HDR workflows—a key metric where JPEG XS previously held a technical advantage. These converged developments suggest that while JPEG XS remains the preference for primary contribution, NDI is rapidly maturing into a viable high-end production alternative.
Read full article at aws.amazon.com
Enjoy our coverage?
Add StreamingMeme as a preferred source on Google to see more of our streaming news at the top of your Search results.
Add as preferred source